Where to start watching South Park
By Robert Scucci | Published: 2025-10-30 14:30:00 | Source: GIANT FREAKIN ROBOT
Written by Robert Scocchi | Updated
Having just begun its twenty-eighth season, South Park It has so many newcomers thanks to its heavy political satire that people can’t seem to get enough of it (personally, I’m done with it). Those who came to toast the news but find themselves curious about it South Park A decades-long legacy might not know where to begin if they wanted to dig deeper.
All Diehard fans agree that the golden age of the series runs between seasons five and ten, and they’re right. Really, any episode up until Season 18 is a clean entry point because Trey Parker and Matt Stone always played fast and loose with continuity before taking a more serialized approach to storytelling in later seasons.
You can go to IMDb and look at the top 100 episodes by audience rating, but that can get overwhelming once you realize how many bands are certified there. Given that this is a solid starting point, I’d like to focus on what I think is the best episode of South Park. At #49 with a rating of 8.6 stars, “Cartman’s Incredible Gift” is the pinnacle of South Park for every reason I’m about to go into.
Buckle up, Buckaroo, because there’s a lot to unpack here.
Cartman’s “amazing gift” is Peak South Park
“Cartman’s Incredible Gift” focuses on boys, and has more merit than you might realize on your first viewing. He criticizes psychics, a line that begins with the season six episode “The Biggest Douche in the Universe,” which spent its runtime criticizing John Edwards for preying on people desperate to reconnect with loved ones who have died. That episode hasn’t aged well either; Although it’s still funny, its humor is tied to a specific era when TV psychics were running wild. The jokes hold up in the typical South Park Fashion, but the more objective approach may be lost on newcomers who don’t remember John Edwards, or weren’t born yet.
“Cartman’s Incredible Gift” takes the same criticism of psychics and gives it a more timeless presentation through parody. Relentlessly quoting films like Red dragon, The giftand Dead zonethis era South Park Satire tends toward the absurd by embracing tropes rather than directly mocking them. Even if you haven’t seen these movies, you’re aware of what’s being made fun of. For those who are more familiar with the source material, the references are made more difficult, adding another layer of humor. It’s the best of both worlds: vague enough for casual viewers but specific enough for people who know what’s being spoofed.
Adults are so stupid, boys are boys
The story in “Cartman’s Amazing Gift” is so simple that it’s stupid. Cartman jumps from his roof thinking he can fly, awakens from a two-day coma (you can remove his face is warmer now), and convinces everyone that a traumatic brain injury gave him psychic powers. Summoned by Sergeant Harrison Yates to help solve a series of murders, Cartman wastes no time in exploiting the situation for money. Kyle, whose BS detector never fails, knows that Cartman is taking advantage of Yates’ incompetence and decides to investigate on his own.
The serial killer, Michael Deets, is out in the open at all times, showing up at active crime scenes wearing a dirty bathrobe rolled over his underwear. It doesn’t take long for Kyle to realize that this is the man who is killing the residents of South Park and cutting off their left hands as trophies. Yates, completely convinced of Cartman’s “powers”, dismisses Kyle’s claims because he is not a psychic.
Kyle’s frustration grows as Cartman’s newfound gift leads to a “telekinetic battle of the minds” with a group of self-proclaimed “true psychics.” Meanwhile, Yates, after forcefully arresting several innocent people thanks to Cartman’s false leads, finally decides to check out the Deets’ house. He finds a trophy room full of severed hands pinned to the wall but insists that the thumb faces the wrong direction, meaning Deets collects right hands, not left ones. He’s clearly a serial killer, but by Yates’s logic he’s not their man.
Back at the precinct, Yates runs complex tests to verify his ridiculous theory. Deets, angry that Cartman gave the wrong citizens of South Park credit for his reign of terror, kidnaps him and tortures him with an endless slideshow of boring vacation photos.
Wall-to-wall gags barely remembered by their creators
South Park has always been produced on a grueling six-day schedule, and Season 8 was particularly tough because Trey Parker and Matt Stone were working on it. Team America: Global Police At the same time.
They were on fire, flying by the seat of their pants, and their little comment about Cartman’s “amazing gift” was evident. When recalling the development of the episode, they only remembered the left-handed gag and a few other stray jokes. They were at the peak of creativity, writing quickly and trusting their instincts. There was no time to overthink.
Unlike current South Park seasons, which now last two or three weeks, Season 8 was pure chaos. This manic, sleepless energy bleeds into “Cartman’s Incredible Gift,” the penultimate episode of that particular outing. The focus on the boys and the incompetence of the adults, as Michael Deets goes on a murderous rampage, gives the episode an unexpected pace and surreal tone that perfectly captures what made this era of the show so great. It’s a bastion of creativity, silliness and humor that remains alive and unfiltered.
If there was an episode to start with, it’s this one
“Cartman’s Amazing Gift” is the one episode I always recommend when people ask where to start South Park. Using parody stretched to the extreme, dark and surreal humor, and self-referential jokes (“She was considered a secondary character, one that fans wouldn’t miss much”), she perfectly captures the balance between the boys’ antics and the goofiness of the adults. Everything that defined Golden Age South Park is here.
“Casa Bonita” and “Scott Tenorman Must Die” may be fan-favorite staples, but “Cartman’s Incredible Gift” just doesn’t have the X factor. With its layered parodies and satisfying sense of humor, South Park is firing on all cylinders.
If you can get through this episode without choking on laughter, you’ll feel right at home starting from the beginning and enjoy everything South Park has to offer.
(Tags for translation) Cartman’s Amazing Gift
ــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــ
